Why accumulated thermal cycling changes what closing needs to deliver
A pool plumbing system is a series of underground pipes, joints, and connections that run between the pool shell and the equipment pad. These joints are typically made of PVC fittings bonded with solvent cement, which creates a strong connection when new but gradually becomes more brittle and less able to flex with age as the solvent and PVC material harden through decades of UV exposure, temperature cycling, and soil movement. Every Pennsylvania winter puts every one of those joints through another full expansion and contraction cycle as temperatures swing from summer highs to below freezing overnight lows.
On a pool installed in 2019 or 2020, those joints have experienced only five or six of these full thermal cycles. The material is still relatively close to its original condition. A blowout that appears clean on these systems is almost certainly a complete blowout, because the joints themselves still have enough structural integrity to prevent low spots or restrictions from forming. The newer the system, the more reliable a clean looking blowout actually is as a confirmation of dry lines.
Montgomeryville changes this calculation directly. The homes throughout this community were built primarily between the mid 1980s and mid 1990s, and the pools installed during that same era now have between 30 and 40 full thermal cycles on every underground joint. That accumulated cycling history narrows the margin for error on the blowout in two specific ways. First, the joint material itself has less structural reserve than it did when new, which means a partial obstruction or a low spot that formed as surrounding soil settled over thirty years is more likely to retain water than an equivalent position in a newer system. Second, the consequences of a blowout that leaves residual water in a fatigued line are potentially more serious, because that same fatigued joint has less ability to withstand the expansion force of ice than a newer joint would.